It's been over a year and a half since I last posted. I've played a few games in that time. I'll get around to reviewing them eventually. All I can say is that lots of life happened and it was overwhelming. But I really hope I'm on the upside of all that and the light at the end of the tunnel is actually the end of the tunnel, not another train headed my way.
On to the rant! (because I know that's really why you're reading this.)
I picked up Roots of Pacha recently. It's pretty much Stardew Valley with a prehistoric flavor. The mechanics are almost the same - you farm, fish, explore, talk to villagers, etc. You tame your animals with the power of your magic flute then invite them to live with you, if you have enough space in your sheds or home. Every day in the game is a round of chores. But if you ignore them, it's okay. There really aren't consequences. Overall, it's a very chill game and very playable.
But...
I wasn't happy with it. I left it for over a week and didn't really want to pick it up again. In trying to figure out why, I realized it's because I'm basically an NPC in the game. Nothing I do matters to anyone except me and even then it isn't important. I'm a passive observer of the village growth. I don't get to experiment with the food I grow and collect to find new recipes. I have to interact with the right person at the right time for them to hand me a recipe. Or expand my kitchen and suddenly, I know how to cook new things. I'm not the one who experiments with new materials or tools to see what I can build. The villagers do that. All of the upgrades and expansions to the village? I get to decide which pre-determined build spot they use but otherwise I have no input whatsoever. My character could die and not a single one of the villagers would notice or care.
I made it through one year of the game and I'm not sure I care about going back for another. I felt like my character mattered more in Animal Crossing, which is a pretty passive game. The endless chores are okay, if that's your vibe, but I want to feel like what I do affects the game in some way. Even the story, what there is of one, in Roots of Pacha doesn't depend on my character's choices or actions, except as a trigger when I've collected so many rocks or some such hidden checkpoint. How am I supposed to have a goal in the game when I have no idea what it takes to meet it because nowhere is it specified?
So I wander around randomly doing random things until suddenly, I've accomplished a goal! Whoopee. There is no sense of accomplishment, no dopamine rush for me. Because I'm not invested in the game because the game gives me no reason to be invested. I'm not a part of the village, I'm a disconnected observer. I don't even matter as much as the other villagers. I'm an outsider with no real influence. If I decide not to grow any food, it doesn't matter to anyone. If I spend the entire day sitting in my hut staring at the wall, no one cares. They have no reason to care about me and I have no reason to care about them.
And no reason to keep playing.